The article argues that the United States’ long-standing dominance in the Middle East has been severely damaged by the recent US-Israel war against Iran and the Gaza war. It says Washington failed to remove Iran’s government, protect Gulf allies or keep the Strait of Hormuz open, undermining the security arrangements established after 1991.

According to the analysis, US policy for 35 years focused on Israel’s security and containing Iran and Iraq, while military bases and security guarantees supported authoritarian regional governments. It contends that wars, sanctions, failed peace efforts and unconditional support for Israel deepened violence, poverty and public resentment across the region.

The article says Gulf states may increasingly make independent choices, including engaging Iran or expanding ties with China and Russia. It argues that Washington could pursue a different approach through diplomacy, shared defense, human rights and pressure on allies to halt abuses, rather than military intervention and support for authoritarian rulers.